Radiology Practices:
Consolidate or Collaborate? 

By: Keith Chew, MHA, CMPE, FRBMA
Senior Consultant, MSN Healthcare Solutions

The business environment for today’s radiology practice is challenging and the alternatives for an independent practice can be daunting.  Is it possible to remain independent or are market forces making consolidation inevitable?  What are some logical alternatives for the group trying to decide what to do?    

  1. Merge or sell to another group or corporate entity
  2. Seek employment with the hospital or other corporate entity
  3. Improve the strategic positioning of the group through collaboration

It should be noted that any option involves an element of risk, especially in terms of the group’s autonomy and of course, doing nothing is also a choice.  Merging and/or becoming employed by another entity naturally implies trade-offs in terms of group autonomy…so what option potentially provides for the best of both worlds; that is, strengthening capabilities while maintaining a functioning practice that is rewarding.

Collaboration Examined

In its initial stages, collaboration may be considered by groups with certain shared circumstances.  Maybe they both cover facilities within the same healthcare system and would like to not only avoid future turf wars but see if they could work together to ease the stress of staffing demands.  Physician leaders, after perhaps casual “what if” conversations, initiate informal discussions to see if there are logical opportunities to work together. 

They begin with the following questions:

  • Are there possible clinical/professional synergies?
  • Are there possible financial synergies?
  • Will the groups be able to work jointly for the benefit of all?
  • Should the groups “work together” or consider merging?

Benefits of Collaboration

What are some of the possible benefits of collaboration/affiliation as opposed to formally merging?  Are there opportunities for:

  • Group purchasing
  • Access to financing
  • Centralizing business offices and human resources management
  • Reduction in insurance costs (medical malpractice, directors and officers, etc.)
  • Reducing costs of employee benefits
  • Timely financial reporting
  • Marketing and brand development
  • Quality Payment Program initiatives (MIPS, MVPs, value-based payments)
  • Improved physician, patient and employee satisfaction
  • Leadership development and succession planning
  • Contracting: Payers, hospitals, tele-coverage, pre-authorization support
  • Technology investments

Joint Ventures: Establishing a Process

At what point do projects or relationships need to move from informal “what if” discussions to a structured mechanism for communicating proprietary/competitive information?  And how can physicians protect their respective practices during the process, especially if they determine after months of discussion that the proposed relationship isn’t going to work after all? 

A distinct process establishes mutually agreed upon steps to ensure comprehensive due diligence is conducted and also develops a structured pathway to terminate the relationship if needed.      

The proposed joint venture enables the groups to:

  • Combine skills and/or technology
  • Allow for revenue synergies or cost saving
  • Leverage resources

The illustration below defines the stages of the new business relationship as it develops.  

MSN radiology practices consolidate or collaborate

Improving Strategic Positioning Through the Joint Venture

The table below illustrates operational areas the joint venture can address, thereby improving the strategic positioning of each of the parties.

operational areas Joint venture can address

Source: https://www.physicianleaders.org/news/medical-groups-driving-engagement-value-success

Do you need a consultant?

Once a decision is made to move past the initial get-acquainted session, there is a recommended discipline for the due diligence that follows.  A business consultant with experience in group governance as well as the legal and financial implications of formalizing a new business relationship can represent a wise investment, as a neutral party directs the sequence of decisions and information sharing.  

radiology billing consultant looking over data on ipad

It is likely one physician practice will be more dominant and it’s easy to second guess motives at critical junctures in the process.  It is also only natural that each group will seek favorable terms and it helps to have a disinterested party direct any compromise. 

The consultant should offer a clear road map with logical decision points.  He/she should also be able to work with legal counsel and financial experts representing each group to ensure critical details are not overlooked. 

The expertise a consultant brings to these discussions could very well mean the difference between a successful collaboration and a disaster with far reaching impacts for both groups.

Contact MSN Healthcare Solutions
About our Practice Management
and Consulting Services

Keith Chew, Senior Practice Management Consultant

Keith Chew

MHA, CMPE, FRBMA

Senior Consultant, MSN Healthcare Solutions

Keith has been a healthcare thought leader for more than 35 years, with experience assisting physicians, hospitals and health systems with practice leadership solutions, management, operations improvement, governance, strategic planning and strategic positioning.  Keith holds multiple degrees and certifications, is a past president of the Radiology Business Management Association (RBMA) and has been a guest speaker for numerous national professional associations.

© MSN Healthcare Solutions. All rights reserved. This document and its contents are proprietary and confidential and may not be copied, reproduced, distributed, modified, or otherwise used without the prior written consent of MSN Healthcare Solutions. This document is provided solely for general educational purposes and may not reflect the most current information or the specific laws, regulations, or requirements applicable to your situation; it does not constitute legal advice or a substitute for applicable laws, regulations, or professional legal counsel. Users are responsible for complying with applicable legal and regulatory requirements and should consult qualified legal counsel as appropriate. Read the full legal disclaimer.

Share this post:

Related Posts

Legal Disclaimer

These educational documents and guides were prepared as a tool to provide education only. It is not intended to affect clinical treatment patterns. The material provided is for informational purposes only. Efforts have been made to ensure the information within this document was accurate on the date of distribution. Reimbursement policies vary from insurer to insurer, and the policies of the same payer may vary within different U.S. regions. All policies should be verified to ensure compliance.

CPT® codes, descriptions, and other data are copyright of the American Medical Association (or such other date of publication of CPT®). All Rights Reserved. CPT® is a registered trademark of the American Medical Association. Proprietary and confidential document.

All rights reserved. These documents and all content contained therein are proprietary and confidential to MSN Healthcare Solutions. No part of these documents may be copied, reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, or used in any form or manner without the prior written consent of MSN Healthcare Solutions. No license or permission to use the content is granted except as expressly authorized in writing. The content does not constitute legal advice or a substitute for applicable laws, regulations, or professional legal counsel.

Proprietary and confidential document.

MSN Services Inquiry

If you would like to learn more about MSN services for your practice, please call us or use the form below.

1-866-567-7405  / Local: 706-653-8150