Medicare audits share a commonality to the degree that each type requires a specific response within a designated timeframe (usually 45 days). They range from verifying accurate payments from Medicare Administrative Contractors (MACs) to follow-up in instances of suspected fraud. While certain audits imply higher levels of risk for a practice, all should be taken seriously in terms of ensuring the group’s timely response.
In May 2025, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) announced the aggressive expansion of its auditing program for Medicare Advantage (MA) plans, including a plan to increase its workforce of coders from 40 to 2,000 by September 1, 2025. Adding the use of enhanced technology, CMS expects to increase auditing activity from 35 records per health plan per year to auditing between 35 and 200 records per year, depending on the size of the health plan.
The challenge for physician groups is not only responding promptly to an increasing volume of documentation requests for various types of audits, but possibly in retrieving older records due to a backlog in Medicare Risk Adjustment Data Validation (RADV) audits from payment years 2018-2024. CMS faces an early-2026 deadline for completion of remaining RADV audits from 2018-2024 so practices may need to prepare for a flurry of related activity related to documentation requests.
Does it seem like there are more audits happening? Maybe, and let’s look at some of the common ones for radiology practices.
Comprehensive Error Rate Testing (CERT) Audits
Focus: Calculate the Medicare Fee-for-Service (FFS) program improper payment rate
Response deadline: 45 days from date of the letter
Comments: The audit reviews post-payment activity to determine the accuracy of Medicare payments and whether the claim should have been denied or paid at another amount, including underpayments and overpayments. A “stratified random sample of Medicare FFS claims is selected for review; supporting documentation is retrieved from the provider or supplier who submitted the claim for payment; and independent medical reviewers review the documentation to determine if the claim was paid properly under Medicare coverage, coding, and billing rules.” Errors can cause the claim to be counted as either a total or partial improper payment in one of the following major categories:
- No documentation
- Insufficient documentation
- Medical necessity
- Incorrect coding or
- Other
CERT audits are used for statistical reporting and not for direct recoupment of payments.
Dive deeper to learn more about CERT audits.
Medicare Risk Adjustment Data Validation (RADV)
Focus: Review the accuracy of payments made by Medicare Advantage Plans
Response deadline: The Medicare Advantage Organization (MAO) normally has 25 weeks to respond with requested documentation. They can in turn request medical record documentation held by physician groups who cared for the audited patients. Physician group response is required “in a timely manner.”
Comments: Medicare Advantage Plans receive risk-adjusted payments based on diagnosis codes submitted to them by physician groups. While annual audits to determine the accuracy of payments are required for each year, CMS fell behind and is now attempting to audit activity for payment years 2018 through 2024. According to a post from the Texas Medical Association (TMA), CMS will use “enhanced technology” to work through the backlog as they verify the accuracy of claim documentation and payments.
Key areas of focus involve ensuring the accuracy and completeness of diagnostic coding, clinical documentation supporting the diagnoses and adherence to Medicare claim submission requirements.
Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) Audits
Focus: Identification and correction of improper Medicare payments
Response deadline: Deadline responding to RAC audit records request is 45 days, with a “discussion period” of 15 calendar days from the date of the demand letter to initiate discussion.
Comments: RAC audits can be triggered by various factors including unusual billing patterns, high-risk or high-dollar procedures, claims with errors such as incorrect coding, claims lacking sufficient documentation to support medical necessity, claims with insufficient documentation to support services billed, patient complaints or duplicate payments. RACS also use software to analyze billing data and identify potential risk areas even without looking at a specific practice.
Targeted, Probe and Educate (TPE) Audit
Focus: Assist providers with high denial rates or unusual billing practices
Response deadline: The deadline for responding to a TPE audit is 45 days
Comments: Common reasons for claim denials, which can indicate potential target areas, include missing physician signatures, documentation that fails to support medical necessity, missing or incomplete information or failure to support eligibility. There is currently a greater use of artificial intelligence and data analytics to analyze claims data and identify improper billing practices. Once the Medicare MAC advises a provider or practice of the reason for the audit, there is a 45-day period to make changes and performance is again monitored during a second 45-day review period. If some claims are still denied during this phase, the provider will be invited to a one-on-one educational session with CMS. The TPE audit involves three rounds of audit activity although significant improvement in rounds one or two can excuse the provider from further review and terminate audit activity. On the other hand, failure to meet requirements by the third round can lead to 100 percent prepayment review, extrapolation, referral to a Recovery Auditor or other action.
Unified Program Integrity Contractor (UPIC)
Focus: Pre- or post-payment review, triggered by suspected fraud
Response deadline: 30 days
Comments: UPICs conduct targeted investigations for CMS to detect and prevent fraud, waste and abuse in the Medicare and Medicaid programs. They analyze data to identify trends or anomalies for indicate improper billing practices and review medical records to ensure services were medically necessary and billed correctly. UPIC audits can lead to recoupment of overpayments, referral to law enforcement, exclusion from Medicare and Medicaid programs, civil penalties and fines as well as criminal prosecution.
Medicaid Audits
It should be noted that audits are not limited to the Medicare program but extend to Medicaid as well. State Medicaid Agencies (SMAs) work with the Unified Program Integrity Contractors (UPICs) to investigate fraud, waste and abuse in the Medicaid program. Providers are expected to respond within 30 days to a UPIC Additional Documentation Request (ADR).
A Government Accountability Office (GAO) report in 2023 noted 60% of the 923 single Medicaid audit findings represented repeated issues, “including overpayments for services provided to beneficiaries and payments to providers not enrolled in Medicaid.” The report noted two key recommendations were being addressed as of June 2024 and it is probably safe to assume Medicaid audits will continue and may increase in frequency.
Medicare Special Investigation Unit (SIU) Audits
The Medicare Special Investigation Unit is a team within private Medicare plans designed to detect, investigate and audit, correct and recover funds from healthcare fraud, waste and abuse within private Medicare plans (Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans). Providers may also be asked to provide information under these audits.
Extrapolation
Extrapolation is a tool often used in Medicare and Medicaid audits to calculate overpayments and represents the potential financial risk related to an audit. For example, a practice submits 50,000 claims annually for a particular modality. Medicare selects 50 claims for an audit and finds errors in eight of them, averaging $100 per error. That represents an error rate of 16% (of the audit sample) and extrapolation then applies the error rate to the entire claim volume of 50,000 and projects an overpayment of $800,000 should be recouped.
Summary/Conclusion
While most of the audits mentioned are initiated by Medicare and Medicaid, audits can also be initiated by private health plans. The important message for both MSN and client groups is that audit notices may blend in with other forms of correspondence and require diligent monitoring since responses are due within short, strict time periods. Audits and requests for additional information have become routine and more frequent. Prompt communication and documentation of response activity are critical.
Claudia Murray
RCC, RCCIR, FRBMA
Senior Vice President, Regulatory Affairs and Corporate Compliance Officer
Claudia brings an extensive background in Medicare regulations, law and billing processes having spent more than 20 years with the Medicare program in various roles. Prior to joining MSN Healthcare Solutions as their full-time compliance officer, Claudia headed a small consulting firm specializing in radiology and other hospital-based specialties. She consulted with MSN for 15 years in designing, implementing and advising on their compliance programs. Currently at MSN, Claudia is responsible for the myriad activities for HIPAA and corporate compliance as well as the Quality Payment Programs, bringing her full circle to CMS regulations and programs.


